He went to Burnley and Newcastle and then….

Its only insulting as they like to be called Spanish.

They are not Spaniards.
So.
I’m insulted if called an Englander instead of English.?
I know your a bright spark but i lived in Spain for 3 years so may have more of an insight than you.
 
Then you should have known it's an insult.

Shouldn't have needed your wife to tell you.
I apologise my mistake in the post above.
My wife was told ‘it’s ‘NOT’an insult’.
Missed that out due to alcohol and her trying to make me watch iPlayer traitors. Yuk!!
However, I’m sure you know many Spaniards shipwrecked from years ago in your neck of the woods.
 
Not sure why so many are quick to write off EH as a potential manager here again unless its a sense of entitlement that we are now too big to have someone EH at the helm and having him back would be a step backwards. Ludicrous. EH has a wealth of PL experience and knows our club inside out. My concern for EH if he ever came back would be Foley and how he likes to sell a player once they're worth a few quid. A la Newcastle. I don't think EH would want to go through that again. Fwiw our current manager isn't up to the job and this is going to be a season of struggle. Competing in the league with this squad is going to be difficult let alone with the added pressures of European football. A squad which will be weaker once Scott leaves , probably in January and potentially Rayan in the summer.
 
Not sure why so many are quick to write off EH as a potential manager here again unless its a sense of entitlement that we are now too big to have someone EH at the helm and having him back would be a step backwards. Ludicrous. EH has a wealth of PL experience and knows our club inside out. My concern for EH if he ever came back would be Foley and how he likes to sell a player once they're worth a few quid. A la Newcastle. I don't think EH would want to go through that again. Fwiw our current manager isn't up to the job and this is going to be a season of struggle. Competing in the league with this squad is going to be difficult let alone with the added pressures of European football. A squad which will be weaker once Scott leaves , probably in January and potentially Rayan in the summer.
I don’t think anyone is suggesting we are too big for Eddie, more the other way around!

I’m not sure what it would say about his ambition if he came back. There are bigger projects for him, not least the national managers job one day.
 
He's pretty young to be a "parachute" manager to save a season.

The PL schedule does get more manageable now - Sunderland, ManU, Leeds, Ipswich Town, Forest, Fulham, Brighton, Hull. I'd give Rose that stretch to put things back on the rails. But if we are still near the bottom after 14 games, it has to mean a change in manager.
 
I don’t think anyone is suggesting we are too big for Eddie, more the other way around!

I’m not sure what it would say about his ambition if he came back. There are bigger projects for him, not least the national managers job one day.
Agree and exactly how I read it. I read an article, possibly linked on this forum, that he's only looking for a top six type club next.
 
Not sure why so many are quick to write off EH as a potential manager here again unless its a sense of entitlement that we are now too big to have someone EH at the helm and having him back would be a step backwards. Ludicrous. EH has a wealth of PL experience and knows our club inside out. My concern for EH if he ever came back would be Foley and how he likes to sell a player once they're worth a few quid. A la Newcastle. I don't think EH would want to go through that again. Fwiw our current manager isn't up to the job and this is going to be a season of struggle. Competing in the league with this squad is going to be difficult let alone with the added pressures of European football. A squad which will be weaker once Scott leaves , probably in January and potentially Rayan in the summer.
I agree with you.

For this to happen Foley would have to be on board and would have to sell himself to Eddie rather than the other way around. Creative financing would need to be involved as the managers salary is counted in SCR, although his assistants are not.

In the alternate universe where I am in charge I would make this move today. Rose seems like a nice man, talented, but he doesn't seem to fit the culture of the club. I think losing much of the back room staff has contributed to that, but yesterday I saw a team of individuals who seemed to need name tags to know each other. That's fatal for a club our size. The season is young, but not that young.

You don't fire a manager unless you have someone better waiting to replace him. So I am in no way calling for Rose to be terminated. I wasn't calling for Gary O'Neil to be terminated, but we had a better manager in waiting. The club made the right decision then.

My priority this year is Europe. We aren't going down. The next two Thursday nights are huge. Sunderland will be informative. But...

The club should be making soft feelers to see if Howe would even consider coming back to rescue the season if things continue to head south. We don't have the luxury of time to break someone in if things continue to head south, at least in terms of Europe. Eddie would largely be plug and play.

And hopefully in two weeks we will be celebrating a four game winning streak and debating where to place the Marco Rose statute. If not...Eddie makes as much sense as anyone.

But then, again, I thought Brooks was one of our better players yesterday until he was pulled. Which may sadly say more about the other performances than David's.
 
IMHO there are two reasons why Eddie isn’t coming back anytime soon:

- he looked completely knackered in his last few months at Newcastle, and probably needs a break;

- he is almost certainly on gardening leave and would face losing his Newcastle salary (bigger than ours you’d think) if he took a new job.
 
I think its too soon for him, regardless of all the local boy stuff.

More to lose than gain by coming back here re career progression. He could command a bigger job still imo.
 

;