Match report v Luton

kirsikka

UTC Legend
--- Game Spins on Webb Shocker ---

After the insipid draw earlier in the week, the Cherries again faced a team in the bottom half of the table at Dean Court. The unfortunate injury to Stanislas from that match meant Tindall rung the changes, with Carter-Vickers in to make his first league start, Smith moving to left wing back to accommodate the returning Stacey and King replacing Junior.

It looked as if it would be the same formation but JT sprung a surprise, pushing King into a central role to support Solanke and with Brooks allowed freedom to roam behind them, not a bad decision given his propensity to wander. It was kind of a 3-4-1-2 that demanded a lot from the two wing backs and needed the respective centre back to also get forward and support out wide.

The Cherries started well with some good possession as Luton again played the role we’ve seen so often this season of sitting in and asking us to break them down, hoping to hit us on the break. Given it’s worked enough times you can understand why.

Luton nearly gifted Bournemouth an early goal when a header back to the keeper was way too soft and looked like it would land for King, only for his outstretched boot to not quite get the contact he hoped for and ending in a tame shot.

On both flanks, the wing backs were prominent in getting forward with Rico acting as a good foil for Smith on the left, helping him to create triangles that worked the Luton defence. Stacey didn’t have an equivalent forward playing centre back on his side but proved adept at making an impact solo with his pace or with whoever happened to be nearby.

At the other end Harry Cornick was chasing everything for Luton, desperate for a hit against his former club. Carter-Vickers showed good reading of the game and skill to clear up and prevent chances from developing for him.

With 25 minutes gone and the game meandering along, the Cherries looked superior without creating too much of note whilst Luton were hanging in there when the game was changed by an officious interjection from referee Webb.

A Begovic clearance to near the halfway line had Lerma leaping into the air to challenge only to be nudged in flight by a Luton player. Knocked out of his trajectory he made the purely natural movement of swinging his arm around to try and regain his equilibrium and prevent himself from landing awkwardly. As part of this, the tips of his fingers scraped across the face of Luton player, Lockyer, standing nearby. Lockyer collapsed with some blood leaking out from the wound created by the trailing hand.

Rather than take a moment to review the whole incident in his mind and realise it came about from the other Luton players’s nudge, the ref combined the sight of blood with Lerma’s pending charges and, at best guess, phrenology to decide it must have been a flailing elbow and whipped out his red card.

It was exactly the kind of incident that three years ago would led to demands from some for VAR as the ref had dropped an absolute clanger. However, given it’s current implementation, VAR would probably have taken seven minutes to keep the red decision as is and added on a penalty for Luton.

In response to going down to ten men, Tindall kept the same personnel on the pitch but had Brooks drop further back into midfield with King and Solanke alternating leading the line or playing in behind the other.

The sending off left Luton looked confused and a tactical mess since they didn’t know what to do with their game plan now they were expected to try and attack. They still didn’t manage that but contrived to look shakier at the back with the ten men playing their way around them only to see multiple almost chances never quite developing into the real thing.

The King and Solanke partnership was a thing of pleasure as they dragged players around and tried to create space for each other. Having earlier this season looked like a player unaware he had teammates, King was playing with an unselfish streak I can’t recall seeing for a long time. He even dummied one ball to allow it to run to a non-existent Cherry when the situation demanded he show some greed and have a crack.

The half time whistle blew and referee Webb was given a non-stop chuntering escort from the pitch all the way down the tunnel from Tindall. The ref’s face didn’t even acknowledge him as his expression looked like he’d mainlined a wholesale delivery of Botox. I assume he’d been made aware over his headset that he’d got it badly wrong and so wanted to get away from the scene of the crime.

The Cherries top brass made it known to media immediately that the red card will be appealed and, undoubtedly, rescinded but that didn’t help matters for the coming 45 minutes.

Immediately from the kick off Luton showed a bit more ambition. A free kick was sent into the back post where an attacker was stood all along after King and another defender had let themselves get dragged into the centre. The Luton player blasted a shot which Begovic somehow deflected only to see it hit Solanke and then trickle past the post. That’s the second time this week we’ve been completely undone by the absolute basics on a meat and drink free kick so that needs to be worked on.

From the corner the ball reached a Luton player in the six yard box and he leathered it at goal only to see Begovic react like a Mantis Shrimp, kicking out a leg to save it with his foot. The ball broke loose and moments later another shot was fired in from further out but heading like an Exocet for the corner only to see the Bosnian once again produce an excellent save to keep it out.

Three times in two minutes he kept out chances that would have beaten most keepers. It was like watching Gandalf face down a Balrog; the ball shall not pass.

After that flurry failed to produce a goal Luton disappeared from the attacking half again as the Cherries belied their smaller numbers to put the visitors under sustained pressure. One King run was like something from his AFCB greatest moments showreel as he ran with pace, power and skill only to slip it through to Solanke at the perfect moment. Dom flicked it past the keeper but didn’t see the covering defender who cleared it before it could roll into the net.

In amongst all the good work from the Cherries there was one black mark. The earlier season set piece foibles had reappeared with corner after free kick after corner being floated in with plenty of air meaning the lamppost Luton had in central defence could clear it easily every time. It was crying out for someone to tell Rico to fire it in with pace but the shout never came.

Finally on 66 minutes Luton dared venture forth into the Bournemouth half again as an attack down the right opened up some space near the box as the player cut inside. He passed it further in to Dewsbury-Hall who had S Cook standing off him allowing him space to take a shot which flew into the net giving Begovic no chance.

Tindall rung the changes, trying to bring on fresh legs to make a difference. With Rico off we did finally see some different set piece deliveries and wonder of wonders one of them almost worked as Steve Cook nodded it back across goal only for it to not land kindly for the Cherries. The key here is though the style of ball in meant it created a problem for Luton.

Once again a series of almost moments characterised the Bournemouth attacks. It felt like it would never drop until finally on 85 minutes Kelly speared in a cross which was met on the volley first time by Riquelme only to see the Luton keeper save it.

That was it. A game we dominated with ten men but lost to a team that only went into our half when they were chased out of theirs. 36% possession when you’ve got a man advantage for over an hour might possibly be a record.

The man on the pitch that made the real difference to the match today though was, unfortunately, the one person you don’t want to be the centre of attention. A ref should never guess what’s happened for such a crucial decision.
 
----- Conclusions -----

- I said after the Millwall game that JT lacked tactically bravery and that cost us the win in that match. In a way, it’s doubly so now because this was a game lost outside of our control. The reason why you have to take the wins on offer is because in football you can miss out in games unjustly. Three points from six wouldn’t have been too bad. One from six is really poor and makes the Millwall result look even worse, no matter the reason for today.

- Conversely, the management and team didn’t lack ambition in this game. If we’d show today’s kind of desire to win against Millwall we’d have run away with it. I’ll say that aside whilst applauding the excellent effort from all concerned in this match.

- I loved what I saw from King out there. Having lambasted him for much of the prior five months it might be time to lay off since if he’s going to be his old self for the remainder of his contract then Championship defenders… watch out!

- I’d like to buy Begovic a pint. At the start of this season that isn’t a sentiment I would have expected to express.

- Despite all the positives we still have problems breaking down the teams that come here to sit in and hope they get lucky. We need to find a solution since we’re going to see it a lot.

- Football is a cruel mistress. We didn’t deserve to lose today. We didn’t deserve to draw today. We didn’t deserve to go down to ten men today. However, the performance was there in stark contrast to Tuesday. That’s what we need to do game in and game out. In the end it will pay off and we’ll look back at today and laugh at the ridiculous official.

- I wouldn’t like to buy David Webb a pint.


----- Player Ratings -----

Begovic – 8 and Man of the Match
Those three saves in two minutes deserved to win us points. They were that good they also get him MotM.

S Cook – 6
Stood off his man for the goal but apart from that not bad.

Carter-Vickers – 7
Looks very tidy indeed. Good anticipation and defensive work.

Rico (off on 71) – 7
Dreadful set piece delivery but, crucially, he was constantly getting forward to support Smith which this system demands. I suspect it would have paid off but for Webb’s intervention.

Stacey (off on 71) – 7
Great energy and pace. A welcome relief to have him back.

Lerma (red card on 26) – 6
Blameless in the sending off. Up until then not much either way.

L Cook – 6
Had to be more circumspect due to the man shortage in the midfield.

A Smith (off on 82) – 7
Combined well with Rico on the left. He isn’t a natural fit there but it seems of the three options he may be the best for this system.

Brooks (off on 82) - 7
Grafted well in the middle when forced to fill in so deserves a lot of credit for that.

Solanke – 7
Worked hard and a little unlucky not to score. Nice link up with King.

King (off on 71) – 7
Probably the best display from him this season. The partnership with Solanke looks like it could be very effective if he puts in more performances like this (and sees his contract out).


--- Subs ---
Billing (on from 71) – 6
One moment of excellent skill and got himself around the pitch.

Kelly (on from 71) – 7
Actually did well in the LWB role and unlucky not to set up the equaliser.

Surridge (on from 71) – 6
One beautiful lay off but quiet aside from that.

Riquelme (on from 82) – 6
Unfortunate not to score. Still seems desperate to impress.

Anthony (on from 82) – 6
Enthusiastic but didn’t quite happen for him in this cameo.


Overall grade: B
It isn’t often I’ll give a grade like that in a match we lost and in which we didn’t score. However, the deck was stacked against us by incompetent refereeing but we still looked by far the better team throughout.

Play that well in that same game and nine times out of ten we’d win. Today was the outlier.

At the same time, previous games are now coming back to haunt us as we’ve been drawn into the chasing pack. We need a run of good results and we need them soon.
 
Great report ......Mantis Shrimp fantastic!
Another poor result from a system that rarely produces anything else....although we looked ok with it until the sending off......agree about the effort and sprit of the players....really can't fault them....i thought Stacey was going to throw up at one stage....he looked absolutely shattered....can't ask for more than that in the circumstances.
 
Good report

If we play with that commitment and 11 for rest of season, we should soon see the luck turn.

You will though find me continuing to support VAR. Concept is fine and we need to stick with it to improve implementation / application. That would have been sorted before the injured player left the pitch, no time impact at all.
 
Last edited:
You will though find me continuing to support VAR. Concept is fine and we need to stick with it to improve implementation / application. That would have been sorted before the injured player left the pitch, no time impact at all.

No time lost on this occasion may be, plenty of interest, excitement, tension, atmosphere, if this had been a match in front of supporters, lost though.

The Dean Court crowd would have been absolutely seething at such a decision, the atmosphere in the ground would have been red hot. The players would have fed off of it and the spectacle would have been vastly different.

With VAR all of that would have been neutered and there's still no guarantee they would have got it right, but the crowd would have been placated by it.

Should the Championship have VAR? Poll - https://bournemouth.vitalfootball.co.uk/snack-poll/should-the-championship-have-var/
 
No time lost on this occasion may be, plenty of interest, excitement, tension, atmosphere, if this had been a match in front of supporters, lost though.

The Dean Court crowd would have been absolutely seething at such a decision, the atmosphere in the ground would have been red hot. The players would have fed off of it and the spectacle would have been vastly different.

With VAR all of that would have been neutered and there's still no guarantee they would have got it right, but the crowd would have been placated by it.

Should the Championship have VAR? Poll - https://bournemouth.vitalfootball.co.uk/snack-poll/should-the-championship-have-var/
Serious! You want to accept bad decisions because it might fire up a crowd. The players looked seething without a crowd. With 11 and no crowd we win that comfortably, especially when VAR takes them to 10 for the dangerous play on Lerma in the air.

It's utter nonsense when Tindall can get feedback that it's a shocker within minutes and view it at half time, but the ref can't even do that to undo his mistake. The only people not allowed to see that replay were the refs.

VAR produces far less controversial decisions than before it started. And it will improve as time goes. For example every player has one of those monitors on their back that could be used as the offside check, just needs a technology upgrade. Less than 10% of goals get overturned and often while a team is slowly making their way back to the other half .

We've lost 6 points this week to 2 dodgy refs, putting team under more pressure than should have to beat Derby, not helped by the less than supportive comments from their fans who are not happy with two good enough performances with a decent ref.

Finally, it says a lot of people, that they don't care about the rules, don't care about fair play and happy to turn a blind eye when they get away with one. Roles reversed, I would have zero joy if I were a Luton fan knowing we didn't deserve to win that with everything that went on. These type of decisions ruin the game far more than a few stops to get the decision right.
 
Serious! You want to accept bad decisions because it might fire up a crowd.

Football is a sport. It’s not a computer game. The players make human errors, the officials make human errors. That’s life, that’s football. That’s what brings passion and emotions to the game.

I don’t want a sterilised environment where I can’t randomly shout at a linesman for offside because I know somewhere in a bunker somewhere someone’s drawing lines to work out if someone is being played onside because he’s got a hairy armpit or that the striker is offside by a toenail that he should have cut two days ago.

It’s utter madness. It’s a shambles, “the concept is right” well maybe the concept of communism is right but it doesn’t mean it will ever work.
 
I think using VAR for checking if a Ref is correct in giving a straight red is a good use of technology. I’m not a fan of a team of mini refs re-refing the game in a video suit.
This striving for a perfectly fair system of applicating all of the rules all of the time will surely result in nullifying some of the passion and talking points IMO. Some will prefer this and some won’t.
If you want completely consistent reffing of football then I think you would need to completely do away with human refs and leave it up to a super computer called ROSS (refs on social security)
 
It’s seems obvious to me we need another midfielder even if that means selling someone like Lewis, Lerma or billing because none of them have been that impressive recently
 
It’s seems obvious to me we need another midfielder even if that means selling someone like Lewis, Lerma or billing because none of them have been that impressive recently
Lewis cook has been excellent this season. Recently on form billing had been very good .
When we high press as a whole team , this is where lerma is good .
 
Still for me everything is intrigate and through the middle .
We need to gamble and play much Higher up the pitch .
We do lack width
 
A midfield with some goal threat would indeed be nice. Having said that I have seen it from this team, I think the latest performance was when we played three in midfield and Billing was rampant in the first 20, both Lerma and Lewis where threatening on the edge of the box.

We do seem to face a lot of teams that get men behind the ball and make it very difficult to break down. We get a lot of possession but struggle to get in. Had the same problem in the Premiere League.
Two things I would look at improving is holding on to the ball better and wearing down the opposition to find some space to get in. All too often we give the ball away with a hopeful pass in the last third. Boring i know but more patience might help but it’s then more difficult to stay positive and not start playing conservatively.
I don’t think we get in behind teams enough with over lapping runs, be that out wide or through the middle.
 
Cook has his moments, but they are more than matched by his wayward passing and running into trouble. Neither he or Brooks seem to able to impose themselves on a game for any length of time.
 
No time lost on this occasion may be, plenty of interest, excitement, tension, atmosphere, if this had been a match in front of supporters, lost though.

The Dean Court crowd would have been absolutely seething at such a decision, the atmosphere in the ground would have been red hot. The players would have fed off of it and the spectacle would have been vastly different.

With VAR all of that would have been neutered and there's still no guarantee they would have got it right, but the crowd would have been placated by it.

Should the Championship have VAR? Poll - https://bournemouth.vitalfootball.co.uk/snack-poll/should-the-championship-have-var/

We have opposing views on here ....can we not just see who 'likes' what?.... :p
 
A midfield with some goal threat would indeed be nice. Having said that I have seen it from this team, I think the latest performance was when we played three in midfield and Billing was rampant in the first 20, both Lerma and Lewis where threatening on the edge of the box.

We do seem to face a lot of teams that get men behind the ball and make it very difficult to break down. We get a lot of possession but struggle to get in. Had the same problem in the Premiere League.
Two things I would look at improving is holding on to the ball better and wearing down the opposition to find some space to get in. All too often we give the ball away with a hopeful pass in the last third. Boring i know but more patience might help but it’s then more difficult to stay positive and not start playing conservatively.
I don’t think we get in behind teams enough with over lapping runs, be that out wide or through the middle.

passing for the sake of passing isn’t always the answer .
In a team you need proper balance . Balance where you can play it around and go from side to side .
At the moment we have no threat from the wide areas whatsoever . Teams just pack the middle against us . Not rocket science when we only look to really go through the middle .
Any time we do go via the wide areas we seem to create a change or half chance
I’m not saying that 442 or 424 is the answer but you would get balance on both sides of the pitch .
 
Great report ......Mantis Shrimp fantastic!
Another poor result from a system that rarely produces anything else....although we looked ok with it until the sending off......agree about the effort and sprit of the players....really can't fault them....i thought Stacey was going to throw up at one stage....he looked absolutely shattered....can't ask for more than that in the circumstances.
Earlier in the season when Others were calling out the system you were defending it and saying it was down to application. Changed your tune
 
Earlier in the season when Others were calling out the system you were defending it and saying it was down to application. Changed your tune
Had you been around you'd have seen that i was highly critical of 343 when Eddie tried it ....what i said at the start of the season was that we had to give JT'S version of it a chance .....(take note) that's what someone with no preconceived agenda or an over inflated ego does.....it could be worse tough as i could have spent all of last seaon slaggingEddie off for playing 442 and then suggest we start using it now!
 
Had you been around you'd have seen that i was highly critical of 343 when Eddie tried it ....what i said at the start of the season was that we had to give JT'S version of it a chance .....(take note) that's what someone with no preconceived agenda or an over inflated ego does.....it could be worse tough as i could have spent all of last seaon slaggingEddie off for playing 442 and then suggest we start using it now!
Lol anyone could see early on that we didn’t have the players to play it. And in terms of now advocating 442, the championship is an entire different ball game. Last season 442 didn’t work as we constantly got overrun in midfield, this season it isn’t so much of an issue with the reduction in quality, and having D Brooks to play as a 10. Just admit you were wrong and move on
 
Lol anyone could see early on that we didn’t have the players to play it. And in terms of now advocating 442, the championship is an entire different ball game. Last season 442 didn’t work as we constantly got overrun in midfield, this season it isn’t so much of an issue with the reduction in quality, and having D Brooks to play as a 10. Just admit you were wrong and move on
Says the guy who reckoned we were better off yesterday with lerma sent off, down to 10, as he was getting in the way!
 

;