SilentAFCB, I disagree, there was a lot of good signs early on, his stats at the time were pretty good. I remember us talking about him and the only real worry was that he wasn't getting through any 90 minutes. For whatever reason, that early promise didn't bear fruit in the long term, who knows why.
I do feel a bit uncomfortable at how many fans seem to have totally written him off already, based on a] ignoring the price tag, he is still a young player who is still learning and b] how many players have had slow starts with Eddie before eventually flourishing. I just don't get how someone can think moaning at him at a stadium will help his game.