Squad balance

kirsikka

UTC Legend
There were definitely some issues with the balance across the whole squad last season. However, I'm starting to feel like some excellent moves are being made to change that.

Afobe, a striker that likes to lead the line, being replaced by Brooks, a natural link man between midfield and attack, is an excellent change as that's exactly what we were often missing last season.

Daniels hasn't been challenged for his position since we got promoted and last season look out of sorts at times. The Rico signing is both good succession planning and the right move.

Since we seem to be back in for Lerma, I'm going to take the leap that he'll get here eventually. An out-and-out destructive DM is something we haven't had since Bartley left and that feels like it was several lifetimes ago. It would open up so many different tactical options in games to have him available.

If I was being greedy I'd still want three more over that.

Mepham or a similar player to grow into that RCB role over the coming seasons.

A RB as a natural alternative option to A Smith. Oh please... a RB. It feels like I've been asking for one of those since forever. Or maybe the last five windows.

A winger / wide attacker. Gradel is gone. Pugh is... well we know what he is. Great to have around the squad. May take a few defenders by surprise but we shouldn't be relying on him to start games this season. Stanislas will likely miss half the season due to injury, just not sure what it will be yet. That leaves Ibe and Fraser. No idea who this would be and haven't seen any links so I guess we aren't in the market but I'd be delighted if we pulled one out of the bag. Or if Mahoney suddenly turned out to have matured into PL ready quality.

If all those arrived there would need to be some outgoings but there have been enough articles about clubs interested in Gosling or Arter that I expect one or the other to go should Lerma arrive. Whilst respecting Gosling's performances towards the end of last season I still hope it would be Arter that stays. Then, I'm a sentimental football fan and not a ruthless football manager so I wouldn't be surprised if it was HA. Just a little sad.

I think Brad Smith's race may be run here as well. In some ways he's been unlucky. First the form of Daniels in his first season and then badly timed injuries when the spot became available in his second meant he never got that run of 5 or 6 games some players need to really start showing what they can do. His career is starting to drift and coming up to his mid-20s being a third choice LB can't be something he would be happy about. I expect him to be at a Championship club by the time the seasons starts.

Another player I think that may be asking questions if all of the above arrived would be Mings. We've all seen there's some player in there but will he get the chance to show it? I would hope he stays with us and he doesn't seem the kind to start agitating but CD competition would be pretty fierce and he is trying to dislodge Ake which is a mountainous task.

Hyndman is a bit of a mystery. He must regret his move here as it hasn't worked out and his former club where he was a fixture is now in the PL. Hard to say what will happen but he may also wish to start again somewhere else. If he is the Surman type that he was touted to be then one more season of patience could see him slip into the squad as Drew's replacement. Maybe a loan somewhere?

A lot of ifs, buts and maybes and EH and JT undoubtedly see things differently than I do. However, I feel like the squad is already starting to balance a lot better even though only two players have arrived. I have lots of confidence for the season ahead!
 
Last edited:
I agree, we need a CB in as cover to Ake and Cook, Francis and Mings which would free up a much needed loan out for Simpson that should be the next priority along with another CM.
 
Good post.

Agree with all except widemen. I think we will be 3-5-2 with full backs wide. Ibe, Stanislas and Fraser will vie for the role behind Wilson and King with Mousset. Brooks will too.

However when the inevitable switch back to 4-4-2 happens after the first performance.....;)
 
I don’t see the need for a winger, especially if we’re going to be playing 3-4-3 like at the end of last season and against Sevilla

King, Mousset, Ibe, Fraser, Stanislas, Brooks and Pugh all give a variety of different options

A RB is only worthwhile if he’s under 21. Otherwise it’s just a waste of a squad place for someone who will be way behind Smith and probably Francis.

Believe we have 2 spare spaces in the squad. A DM and a RCB would be amazing. Not sure we’d have enough in the kitty left for both, especially if we end up paying £25m for Lerma.
 
Rico seems to be more a wing back than a full back. I could see him playing outside Mings, with Tyrone as the left CB in a three. And I think there is still plenty of mileage in Charlie, especially in the resolute 4:4:2 with Pugh in front of him. I like those options.
 
Not sure Mings will ever be the answer unfortunately. Just don't think he has the body of a Premier League footballer and definitely can't be relied on too fill in a space when playing 3 at the back.

Apart from United away, even when he has played I've never seen anything to suggest he's good enough for us.

Would love him to prove me wrong
 
H
Not sure Mings will ever be the answer unfortunately. Just don't think he has the body of a Premier League footballer and definitely can't be relied on too fill in a space when playing 3 at the back.

Apart from United away, even when he has played I've never seen anything to suggest he's good enough for us.

Would love him to prove me wrong

He will come good I’m sure. He looked like a man possessed against Sevilla
 

;