It’s common leadership theory that your greatest strength is also your greatest weakness. The world’s greatest leaders in all fields find a way to overcome their strengths becoming their weakness.
Eddie is clearly stubborn. He put together a style of football years ago that everybody said wouldnt work in the championship and he refused to listen or change. By bucking the trend and ignoring everyone, even after two consecutive five goal defeats, he produced the best side the championship had ever seen.
Moving up to the prem all the experts pointed out that he would have to change. He ignored them completely and that side continued to play a style of football suicide that was a joy to watch, took some hammerings for sure, but comfortably stayed in the league providing huge entertainment. Every expert advice ignored.
After three years of blitzkreig football and the goals against column bleeding Eddie decided an evolution was needed. He wanted to protect his back four by sitting deeper and crucially not using his full backs as second wingers. It started well for half a season because teams set up against us expecting the old Bournemouth and were caught out. By the second time they played us they had it sussed probably delighted as we had become a far easier team to play against as we had self nullified our key strength.
No longer attacking sides means our defence is under constant pressure and even bang average sides beat us comfortably something that didn’t happen often in our first few seasons. Once again the experts are seeing the issue and calling it. We can all see it. You can see the players can see it. Eddie remains as stubborn as ever, hence not changing in three months of down time. As he has assembled what I would imagine to be an unchallenging coaching team you wonder if they have the ability to question it.
Does Eddie deserve a chance if we go down... yes in my book as he is proven at that level and look what he did for us.... you deserve a bad year or two after that. People should show more respect. I don’t think he will want to stay though and that’s the bigger problem for us as a club as we haven’t the infrastructure to recreate what was a magical stubborn fluke. We shouldn’t get above ourselves. We are built on one man.