Bill Foley is a very, very successful businessman. He’s also got a pretty good track record of managing sports clubs with the Knights success and all that. If he has now come to the conclusion that our recruitment hasn’t been good enough, fair enough.
I’m not going to sit here and pretend I wasn’t excited by this window, but in hindsight, there are more than a few strange decisions. Main issues for me being the lack of a clearly defined strategy with the signings and how they would fit into the team, and the lack of signings that seem to have been signed to compliment AI’s style of play.
The lack of a competent specialised left back to compete with Kerkez has already cost us points. The lack of a specialised CDM to compete with Cook has cost us points. The lack of a competent striker to compete with Solanke may well have cost us points. And IMO, the lack of PL experience and seniority in the starting lineup has been incredibly destructive so far. These aren’t exactly secrets, either.
We perhaps shouldn’t have signed Traore in hindsight, which is £20 ish million that could’ve been spent on Viña and someone like Stephens with change. But then, there didn’t seem to be much of a plan for who’d actually be in charge this season, and the fact that it was a loan with an obligation to buy has snookered everyone involved a little. Which is a shame because I think Traore is a good player.
The Adams signings is a car crash. Another good player, but one that no one else wanted to sign for his injuries. If there was one position we needed to get right it was CDM, with Lerma leaving and the role’s importance in the new strategy. I’m a bit surprised we didn’t just go for Rayo’s CDM, a player that would’ve had invaluable experience in this specific style of play and probably been cheapish. Could’ve also been AI’s “guy” in the dressing room. Idk.
I’ve said it before but I think we should’ve gone for a Newcastle-lite approach. A few exciting Hollywood signings if it’s needed, in amongst sensible, seasoned pros. To this day, the way we messed Viña around and then proceeded to not even sign him is one of the most baffling misfires I’ve seen from a board perspective. A goal threat from LB who was solid defensively, available for £13 million. Literally why not? And the way he hung around in Bournemouth for like 2 months leaves a bit of a sour taste in my mouth, not a fan. It seems like we saw an opportunity to get another FM wonder kid and then ditched the whole idea. I like Kerkez, but he’s not been any better than Viña - and we could’ve had both, couldn’t we?
Going off on a tangent now. It’s fine margins and I’m not someone that’s going to clamour for Hughes or Blake to lose their jobs. I don’t know enough about that world. But I can see why the decisions been made, and ultimately, I think Foleys (informed by advisors) instincts have been pretty good so far. I think ditching O’Neil was “harsh” but absolutely correct, and I think backing AI is correct.